Joscha Bach: Why Consciousness Is Computation All the Way Down
I personally subscribe to The Economist. TOE listeners get 35% off the annual subscription. No other podcast has this! https://economist.com/TOE
Joscha Bach explores the nature of intelligence, consciousness, and reality, tackling questions from the definition of truth to the existence of free will. He contrasts various theories of consciousness, discusses the role of art and society, and presents his own model of control, attention, and reflective recall.
0:00 Introduction
0:17 Work ethic and daily routine
1:35 Definition of truth
4:41 Quantum graph as nature's substratum
6:25 Mathematics as language descriptor
13:52 Constructivist mathematics and reality
17:06 Meaning of existence and pi
20:14 Something vs nothing, existence default
21:11 Bach's model vs multiverse
26:51 Is the universe deterministic
28:23 Determining initial conditions and rules
30:55 Nature of time, fundamental?
34:21 Optimal algorithm for finding truth
40:40 Simplicity of fundamental laws
50:17 Art and the artist's cost function
54:02 Ideas as stories driven by intuitions
58:00 Society's minimal role in training intuitions
59:24 Art under repressive government
1:04 01 Market case for civil rights
1:06 40 Fascism vs communism
1:10 50 Control/attention/reflective recall model
1:13 32 Consciousness vs attention
1:16 02 Chinese Room experiment
1:25 22 Understanding predicated on consciousness
1:26 22 Integrated Information Theory (IIT)
1:30 15 Donald Hoffman's consciousness theory
1:32 40 Hofstadter's strange loop theory
1:34 10 Holonomic brain theory
1:34 42 Dennett's consciousness theory
1:36 57 Sensorimotor (embodied cognition) theory
1:44 39 What is intelligence?
1:45 08 Intelligence vs consciousness
1:46 36 Free will in Bach's model
1:48 46 Opposite of free will and addiction
1:51 48 Changing identity to live forever
1:59 13 Depersonalization and illusory self
2:02 25 Fear of loss of control
2:05 00 Heart and conscience
2:07 28 Testing/falsifying Bach's consciousness model
2:13 46 Evolution of Bach's model
2:14 41 Stopping lucid dreaming
2:15 33 Dreams and GANs
2:18 08 Why we don't remember dreams
2:19 58 Are dreams real? Is reality a dream?
2:20 39 Practically improving experience
2:23 56 What matters more than survival?
2:28 27 Bach's identity
2:29 44 Is hating humanity objectively wrong?
2:30 31 Practical Platonism
2:33 00 What "God" is
2:36 24 Gods as real as you claim
2:37 44 Nature of prayer and its effect
2:41 06 Society losing future and culture
2:43 24 Disagreement with Jordan Peterson
2:47 16 Millennials as authoritarian generation
2:48 31 Views on social justice movement
2:51 29 UBI vs social inequality and AGI
2:57 39 Nested hierarchy of "I"s
2:59 22 Innovation as "cheating" in USA
3:02 27 Activists operating on false info
3:03 04 Bach's Marxist roots and lessons
3:08 45 BONUS BIT: Societal problems
RESOURCES:
- YouTube link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MNBxfrmfmI
0:00 Introduction
0:17 Work ethic and daily routine
1:35 Definition of truth
4:41 Quantum graph as nature's substratum
6:25 Mathematics as language descriptor
13:52 Constructivist mathematics and reality
17:06 Meaning of existence and pi
20:14 Something vs nothing, existence default
21:11 Bach's model vs multiverse
26:51 Is the universe deterministic
28:23 Determining initial conditions and rules
30:55 Nature of time, fundamental?
34:21 Optimal algorithm for finding truth
40:40 Simplicity of fundamental laws
50:17 Art and the artist's cost function
54:02 Ideas as stories driven by intuitions
58:00 Society's minimal role in training intuitions
59:24 Art under repressive government
1:04 01 Market case for civil rights
1:06 40 Fascism vs communism
1:10 50 Control/attention/reflective recall model
1:13 32 Consciousness vs attention
1:16 02 Chinese Room experiment
1:25 22 Understanding predicated on consciousness
1:26 22 Integrated Information Theory (IIT)
1:30 15 Donald Hoffman's consciousness theory
1:32 40 Hofstadter's strange loop theory
1:34 10 Holonomic brain theory
1:34 42 Dennett's consciousness theory
1:36 57 Sensorimotor (embodied cognition) theory
1:44 39 What is intelligence?
1:45 08 Intelligence vs consciousness
1:46 36 Free will in Bach's model
1:48 46 Opposite of free will and addiction
1:51 48 Changing identity to live forever
1:59 13 Depersonalization and illusory self
2:02 25 Fear of loss of control
2:05 00 Heart and conscience
2:07 28 Testing/falsifying Bach's consciousness model
2:13 46 Evolution of Bach's model
2:14 41 Stopping lucid dreaming
2:15 33 Dreams and GANs
2:18 08 Why we don't remember dreams
2:19 58 Are dreams real? Is reality a dream?
2:20 39 Practically improving experience
2:23 56 What matters more than survival?
2:28 27 Bach's identity
2:29 44 Is hating humanity objectively wrong?
2:30 31 Practical Platonism
2:33 00 What "God" is
2:36 24 Gods as real as you claim
2:37 44 Nature of prayer and its effect
2:41 06 Society losing future and culture
2:43 24 Disagreement with Jordan Peterson
2:47 16 Millennials as authoritarian generation
2:48 31 Views on social justice movement
2:51 29 UBI vs social inequality and AGI
2:57 39 Nested hierarchy of "I"s
2:59 22 Innovation as "cheating" in USA
3:02 27 Activists operating on false info
3:03 04 Bach's Marxist roots and lessons
3:08 45 BONUS BIT: Societal problems
RESOURCES:
- YouTube link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MNBxfrmfmI
Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal features long-form, technically detailed interviews with leading researchers in physics, mathematics, consciousness, and philosophy, exploring topics at the level of active research. For academics, graduate students, and anyone seeking depth beyond popular science.
FOLLOW: Substack | Spotify | YouTube | Twitter
- Crypto: https://nowpayments.io/donation/TOE
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
More description
I personally subscribe to The Economist. TOE listeners get 35% off the annual subscription. No other podcast has this! https://economist.com/TOE
Joscha Bach explores the nature of intelligence, consciousness, and reality, tackling questions from the definition of truth to the existence of free will. He contrasts various theories of consciousness, discusses the role of art and society, and presents his own model of control, attention, and reflective recall.
0:00 Introduction
0:17 Work ethic and daily routine
1:35 Definition of truth
4:41 Quantum graph as nature's substratum
6:25 Mathematics as language descriptor
13:52 Constructivist mathematics and reality
17:06 Meaning of existence and pi
20:14 Something vs nothing, existence default
21:11 Bach's model vs multiverse
26:51 Is the universe deterministic
28:23 Determining initial conditions and rules
30:55 Nature of time, fundamental?
34:21 Optimal algorithm for finding truth
40:40 Simplicity of fundamental laws
50:17 Art and the artist's cost function
54:02 Ideas as stories driven by intuitions
58:00 Society's minimal role in training intuitions
59:24 Art under repressive government
1:04 01 Market case for civil rights
1:06 40 Fascism vs communism
1:10 50 Control/attention/reflective recall model
1:13 32 Consciousness vs attention
1:16 02 Chinese Room experiment
1:25 22 Understanding predicated on consciousness
1:26 22 Integrated Information Theory (IIT)
1:30 15 Donald Hoffman's consciousness theory
1:32 40 Hofstadter's strange loop theory
1:34 10 Holonomic brain theory
1:34 42 Dennett's consciousness theory
1:36 57 Sensorimotor (embodied cognition) theory
1:44 39 What is intelligence?
1:45 08 Intelligence vs consciousness
1:46 36 Free will in Bach's model
1:48 46 Opposite of free will and addiction
1:51 48 Changing identity to live forever
1:59 13 Depersonalization and illusory self
2:02 25 Fear of loss of control
2:05 00 Heart and conscience
2:07 28 Testing/falsifying Bach's consciousness model
2:13 46 Evolution of Bach's model
2:14 41 Stopping lucid dreaming
2:15 33 Dreams and GANs
2:18 08 Why we don't remember dreams
2:19 58 Are dreams real? Is reality a dream?
2:20 39 Practically improving experience
2:23 56 What matters more than survival?
2:28 27 Bach's identity
2:29 44 Is hating humanity objectively wrong?
2:30 31 Practical Platonism
2:33 00 What "God" is
2:36 24 Gods as real as you claim
2:37 44 Nature of prayer and its effect
2:41 06 Society losing future and culture
2:43 24 Disagreement with Jordan Peterson
2:47 16 Millennials as authoritarian generation
2:48 31 Views on social justice movement
2:51 29 UBI vs social inequality and AGI
2:57 39 Nested hierarchy of "I"s
2:59 22 Innovation as "cheating" in USA
3:02 27 Activists operating on false info
3:03 04 Bach's Marxist roots and lessons
3:08 45 BONUS BIT: Societal problems
RESOURCES:
- YouTube link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MNBxfrmfmI
0:00 Introduction
0:17 Work ethic and daily routine
1:35 Definition of truth
4:41 Quantum graph as nature's substratum
6:25 Mathematics as language descriptor
13:52 Constructivist mathematics and reality
17:06 Meaning of existence and pi
20:14 Something vs nothing, existence default
21:11 Bach's model vs multiverse
26:51 Is the universe deterministic
28:23 Determining initial conditions and rules
30:55 Nature of time, fundamental?
34:21 Optimal algorithm for finding truth
40:40 Simplicity of fundamental laws
50:17 Art and the artist's cost function
54:02 Ideas as stories driven by intuitions
58:00 Society's minimal role in training intuitions
59:24 Art under repressive government
1:04 01 Market case for civil rights
1:06 40 Fascism vs communism
1:10 50 Control/attention/reflective recall model
1:13 32 Consciousness vs attention
1:16 02 Chinese Room experiment
1:25 22 Understanding predicated on consciousness
1:26 22 Integrated Information Theory (IIT)
1:30 15 Donald Hoffman's consciousness theory
1:32 40 Hofstadter's strange loop theory
1:34 10 Holonomic brain theory
1:34 42 Dennett's consciousness theory
1:36 57 Sensorimotor (embodied cognition) theory
1:44 39 What is intelligence?
1:45 08 Intelligence vs consciousness
1:46 36 Free will in Bach's model
1:48 46 Opposite of free will and addiction
1:51 48 Changing identity to live forever
1:59 13 Depersonalization and illusory self
2:02 25 Fear of loss of control
2:05 00 Heart and conscience
2:07 28 Testing/falsifying Bach's consciousness model
2:13 46 Evolution of Bach's model
2:14 41 Stopping lucid dreaming
2:15 33 Dreams and GANs
2:18 08 Why we don't remember dreams
2:19 58 Are dreams real? Is reality a dream?
2:20 39 Practically improving experience
2:23 56 What matters more than survival?
2:28 27 Bach's identity
2:29 44 Is hating humanity objectively wrong?
2:30 31 Practical Platonism
2:33 00 What "God" is
2:36 24 Gods as real as you claim
2:37 44 Nature of prayer and its effect
2:41 06 Society losing future and culture
2:43 24 Disagreement with Jordan Peterson
2:47 16 Millennials as authoritarian generation
2:48 31 Views on social justice movement
2:51 29 UBI vs social inequality and AGI
2:57 39 Nested hierarchy of "I"s
2:59 22 Innovation as "cheating" in USA
3:02 27 Activists operating on false info
3:03 04 Bach's Marxist roots and lessons
3:08 45 BONUS BIT: Societal problems
RESOURCES:
- YouTube link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MNBxfrmfmI
Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal features long-form, technically detailed interviews with leading researchers in physics, mathematics, consciousness, and philosophy, exploring topics at the level of active research. For academics, graduate students, and anyone seeking depth beyond popular science.
FOLLOW: Substack | Spotify | YouTube | Twitter
- Crypto: https://nowpayments.io/donation/TOE
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
2020-10-07
199 min
Listen elsewhere
Available Results
Generated results are saved to your library for reuse and search.
No generated results are available for this episode yet.
Transcript
No transcript is available for this episode yet.
Sign in to generate a transcript for review.
Sign in
Chapters
No chapters available.