Co-Chief NYT Restaurant Critic Ligaya Mishan on Succeeding Pete Wells, Her Most Controversial Reviews, and Branching Out from NYC

The Chef's Cut

In a Chef’s Cut first, Adrienne and Joe sit down with co-chief restaurant critic for the New York Times, Ligaya Mishan. They ask her all about taking over for Pete Wells and what goes into writing her reviews every week. Plus, we discuss:

  • The controversial Alinea review everyone is talking about

  • Whether or not a one-star review should be considered "good"

  • How the NYT picks restaurants to review

  • The standards for reviewing a restaurant, including how soon is too soon and how much she eats

  • Is it easy to get a reservation as a NYT critic (and does she get recognized)?

  • Should critics have to read their reviews face-to-face with the people they’re criticizing?

  • The influence of social media on restaurant reviews

  • Ligaya’s favorite chef and which restaurant she wishes should could eat at

Follow Ligaya: @ligayamishan

Follow the show: @chefscutpod

Follow Adrienne: @chefadriennecheatham 

Follow Joe: @insta.flamm


More description

In a Chef’s Cut first, Adrienne and Joe sit down with co-chief restaurant critic for the New York Times, Ligaya Mishan. They ask her all about taking over for Pete Wells and what goes into writing her reviews every week. Plus, we discuss:

  • The controversial Alinea review everyone is talking about

  • Whether or not a one-star review should be considered "good"

  • How the NYT picks restaurants to review

  • The standards for reviewing a restaurant, including how soon is too soon and how much she eats

  • Is it easy to get a reservation as a NYT critic (and does she get recognized)?

  • Should critics have to read their reviews face-to-face with the people they’re criticizing?

  • The influence of social media on restaurant reviews

  • Ligaya’s favorite chef and which restaurant she wishes should could eat at

Follow Ligaya: @ligayamishan

Follow the show: @chefscutpod

Follow Adrienne: @chefadriennecheatham 

Follow Joe: @insta.flamm


2025-11-03 58 min
Listen elsewhere

Available Results

Generated results are saved to your library for reuse and search.

No generated results are available for this episode yet.

Transcript

No transcript is available for this episode yet.
Sign in to generate a transcript for review.
Sign in

Chapters

No chapters available.